Balance of money and house, real estate market concept

How Rising Property Insurance Costs Are Affecting Home Buyers in 2025

Prospective home buyers are facing an increasingly complex market as we approach the spring and summer markets. Rising property insurance costs are another major factor impacting affordability and mortgage approvals. Understanding homeowners insurance trends is crucial for buyers to make informed decisions.​

Rising Insurance Premiums and Home Affordability

Homeowners insurance premiums have surged in recent years, driven by factors such as increased frequency of natural disasters and higher rebuilding costs. Studies indicate that homeowners insurance prices increased by approximately 20% between 2020 and 2023, and they have continued to rise steadily in the years since. This escalation adds a substantial burden to monthly housing expenses, making homeownership less attainable for many.​

Challenges in Mortgage Approvals

Lenders consider the total cost of homeownership when evaluating mortgage applications, which includes principal, interest, taxes and insurance (PITI). As insurance premiums rise, the overall PITI increases. This can potentially push debt-to-income ratios beyond acceptable limits. This scenario can lead to higher interest rates or even denials of mortgage applications, particularly affecting first-time buyers and those with tighter budgets. ​

Regional Disparities and Specific Concerns

The impact of rising insurance costs varies by region, with disaster-prone areas experiencing more significant increases. For instance, homeowners in states like Florida and California have seen substantial premium hikes due to heightened risks of hurricanes and wildfires.

Pennsylvania Homeowners Facing Coverage Challenges

In our area, certain property features have even led to unexpected insurance challenges. Homes with roofs flatter than a certain angle are often deemed higher risk due to potential water pooling and leakage issues. Some providers are adjusting their standards without warning, with some requiring roofs to have at least a 20-degree slope. Consequently, some homeowners have faced policy cancellations or increased premiums.

What Buyers Need to Know Before Making an Offer

Given these challenges, prospective buyers should:

  1. Research Insurance Costs Early: Obtain insurance quotes during the home shopping process to understand potential premiums and factor them into affordability calculations.​
  2. Assess Property Features: Be aware of property characteristics that may affect insurability, such as roof type, age and condition. Homes with flat roofs or outdated electrical systems may pose higher risks and lead to increased premiums or coverage difficulties.​
  3. Consult with Insurance Professionals: Engage with insurance agents to explore coverage options and identify any potential issues with the property that could affect insurance availability or cost.​
  4. Consider Risk Mitigation Measures: Implementing safety features, such as installing storm shutters or updating roofing materials, can reduce risk and potentially lower insurance premiums.​
  5. Review Policy Details Thoroughly: Understand what is covered, policy limits, and any exclusions to ensure adequate protection and avoid surprises during claims.​

By proactively addressing these factors, home buyers can better navigate the complexities of the current market, ensuring they secure both suitable housing and manageable insurance coverage.

It is also beneficial to work with an experienced real estate team that can help you navigate all the complexities of the ever-evolving housing market. If you are planning to buy a home in the Southeastern Pennsylvania or Northern Delaware areas in 2025, contact The Cyr Team today for personalized guidance.

Share this post